Glossary entry

English term or phrase:

"Laid the cup down"

English answer:

It is a bit odd, but not really questionable.

Added to glossary by Jenni Lukac (X)
Feb 27, 2014 21:08
10 yrs ago
English term

"Laid the cup down"

English Art/Literary Art, Arts & Crafts, Painting
I am surprised to see Murdoch, the Sandcastle,writing : he laid the cup down...
The difference, in my book, between put and lay has to do with the size and shape of the object of the verb. You can lay something down that has a certain area and length, such a carpet and a long plank. What do you Anglos think ?
Change log

Mar 13, 2014 09:18: Jenni Lukac (X) Created KOG entry

Discussion

What kind of cup was it? What was the context?
acetran Feb 28, 2014:
Did you try googling it before posting it here?
Tony M Feb 27, 2014:
@ Asker I think you are possibly getting confused between the transitive verb 'to lay' — which is what might apply to carpets, lino, flooring, planks, tiles, etc. — and this verb, which it 'to lay down'; this would not normally be used for flooring etc., but rather suggests the act of putting something in a horizontal position (sometimes, when it might normally be vertical); whence my idea of laying the cup down on its side, possibly to indicate that he didn't want to be served any more. When reading, you probably hold your book up, so "When his grandson came into the room, he laid down his book on the table and took the little lad in his arms."

Responses

+7
5 mins
Selected

It is a bit odd, but not really questionable.

It would be more common to say "set the cup down". You are right in observing that "laid" is more often used for flat objects - for example, "He laid the book down".
Peer comment(s):

agree DLyons : Probably describes the manner of doing it - with care.
11 mins
Thanks, D. Lyons. That's a very plausible motive.
agree Tony M : It could, of course, have been deliberately used to suggest that he laid it down on its side, instead of standing it up, as normal; this might be, for example, to indicate that the cup was empty, or he didn't want any more (cf. chess, laying king down)
49 mins
Thanks, Tony. This example does make me itchy to pick up a red pencil, but "if it ain't really broke..."
agree Jack Doughty
1 hr
Thanks, Jack. I'm about to lay my work aside and lay me down to sleep.
agree Václav Pinkava : ... deliberately, and carefully, with auspicious intent, perhaps
2 hrs
Thanks, Václav. That may well be the reason. Have a good weekend.
agree Yvonne Gallagher : don't really see a problem...
13 hrs
Thanks, gallagy. Have a great weekend.
agree katsy : for me, as for others, it implies putting it down deliberately and carefully
17 hrs
Thanks very much, katsy.
agree Natalia Volkova
1 day 0 min
Cheers and thanks, Natalia.
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Selected automatically based on peer agreement."
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search